Working Money magazine.  The investors' magazine.


Article Archive | Search | Subscribe/Renew | Login | Free Trial | Reader Service



A Full Cuppa JOE

04/28/10 01:16:37 PM PST
by Alexander Elder, MD is a group of 20 professional and semiprofessional traders involved in a weekly competition. Each member submits his or her pick along with the entry, target, and stop. The picks are submitted in private, and then all is revealed on Sunday afternoon. At the end of each week, the Spiker who wins that week's competition writes up his or her analysis of the trade.

In this article I will review the winning trade from the week ended March 19, 2010. The trader is Stephen M., a serious semipro. Steve is the newest Spiker, but he delivered the best performance of any Spiker during the first quarter of 2010, earning a diploma and a check. You can see his profile and the description of his trading style on the website. Here is his review and analysis of his latest winning trade. — AE

Florida-based real estate development company St. Joe Co. (JOE) is an interest rate-sensitive stock that the shorts have been all over recently. They loaded up as JOE bumped its support. While they were preoccupied with the expected rate change from the Federal Reserve, they were blind to the upward pressure from the undulating daily chart pattern that indicated bullishness (Figure 1).

FIGURE 1: JOE’S SMOKIN’. On this daily chart of JOE, note the upward pressure that indicated bullishness.

This slow rise caused the impulse system to change from red to blue and then to green. Soon the squeeze was on and the shorts panicked. The 4.9% surge on Wednesday, March 17, penetrated resistance as the shorts scrambled to cover (Figure 2).

FIGURE 2: MANAGING THE TRADE. Here you see the entry and exit points of the trade. Not too shabby.

  • Entry: I expected to enter on a pullback to 27.57, but JOE gapped up to 28.00 at the opening on Monday, March 15, 2010. I raised my entry order to the previous day’s high, expecting the gap to fill. It did — and then proceeded to slide down to 27.38. JOE rebounded and started building momentum from there.
  • Stop: Once filled, I placed my stop under the March low at 26.92.
  • Target: Just under the February high at 29.75. On March 17, JOE surged up to 29.32, and then pulled back from this resistance point. It already rose $1.00 that day, which was more than double the average daily trading range. I decided to lower my target to 29.32 and take a profit (Figure 3).

FIGURE 3: THE EXIT. On March 17, 2010, JOE surged up to 29.32, and then pulled back from this resistance point. It had already gone up $1.00 on that day, which was more than double the average daily trading range. At this point, the trader decided to lower his target to 29.32 and take a profit.

In conclusion, I felt that the Fed was not going to rock the market at this critical moment in the administration’s political future. This trade looked very appealing, with so many ready to panic if the price didn’t move their way.

The main lesson of this trade is that there are times when pivotal events can induce panic in a crowd that has been caught off-guard. On the minus side, I certainly could have been more patient with my entry by waiting for the upside reversal on the five- or 10-minute chart before pulling the trigger. Finally, the exit is where most of my careful and rational decisions should have been made. Normally, I use the five-minute chart for entries but only the 39-minute chart for exits. In this case, I got caught up in the short-term weakness forming on the five-minute chart and closed the position too early. There was an opportunity cost of this mistake: a 5.77% gain could have been 9.3%. The gain was nice, but the rule wasn’t followed, and that can lead to costly mistakes down the road unless corrected. —Stephen M.

Alexander Elder’s comments: Steve wrote his report in the heat of the battle — at the end of the week during which he made his short-term trade. By the time I sat down to write this review two weeks later, Steve’s trade had moved closer to the middle of the chart. That’s where all signals look absolutely clear, but unfortunately, I have not yet found a broker who will accept my trading orders in the middle of the chart. As traders, we must make our decisions at the right edge, and that’s where the picture is much foggier.

FIGURE 4: THE RIGHT EDGE. Any trade that captures more than 30% of the trade is an excellent trade. This trade certainly met that criterion.

Point 1 on the daily chart (Figure 4) indicates Steve’s entry, point 2 his exit, and point 3 shows where he wrote his comments. Here are my observations about his trade:

  • Long JOE was an excellent swing trade. Steve entered very near the value zone between the exponential moving averages. He took profits near the upper channel line, which marks the overvalued area. I consider any trade that captures 30% or more of the daily channel an A trade. JOE’s daily channel when Steve entered was just about $4 tall. Steve’s trade captured $1.60 — 40% of the channel, an A+.
  • Successful short-term trades can often be converted to long-term trades. Many traders hang on to their losers but quickly get rid of gainers. My partner in SpikeTrade, Kerry Lovvorn, is fond of pointing out how many Spike picks work out better over a three-week time horizon than they do in a single week. In the SpikeTrade competition, the duration is limited to one week. Figure 4 clearly shows an even greater potential of a longer-term view.
  • Will this trader be able to switch from buying to shorting when the market trend changes? The first quarter of 2010 was the time to be long, and Steve won the race during many weeks, earning his gold for the quarter. The market is a two-way street, and when the market changes its trend, we’ll find out how well Steve can handle a downtrend.

The SpikeTrade competition runs 52 weeks a year, and in our next article we will review another winning trade. Let’s see what lesson we can learn next month.

Elder, Alexander [2010]. “The Rubber Band Effect,” Technical
   Analysis of
STOCKS & COMMODITIES, Volume 28: June.
_____ [2010. “Channel Trade Win,” Technical
   Analysis of
_____ [2010]. “A Gem In The Junk Pile,” Technical
   Analysis of
STOCKS & COMMODITIES, Volume 28: Bonus Issue.
_____ [2010]. “How I Won My Gold,” Technical
   Analysis of
STOCKS & COMMODITIES, Volume 28: January.
_____ [2006]. Entries & Exits: Visits To 16 Trading Rooms, John Wiley & Sons.

Alexander Elder, MD

Alexander Elder is a professional trader based in New York City. He is the author of Come Into My Trading Room (Barron’s 2002 Book of the Year) and Trading For A Living, considered modern classics among traders. He also wrote Entries & Exits and Sell and Sell Short. He runs with Kerry Lovvorn, a professional trader from Alabama. He may be reached at

Comments or Questions? Article Usefulness
5 (most useful)
1 (least useful)


S&C Subscription/Renewal

Request Information From Our Sponsors 

DEPARTMENTS: Advertising | Editorial | Circulation | Contact Us | BY PHONE: (206) 938-0570

PTSK — The Professional Traders' Starter Kit
Home — S&C Magazine | Working Money Magazine | Advantage | Online Store | Traders’ Resource
Add a Product to Traders’ Resource | Message Boards | Subscribe/Renew | Free Trial Issue | Article Code | Search

Copyright © 1982–2021 Technical Analysis, Inc. All rights reserved. Read our disclaimer & privacy statement.